When in doubt….Check your Premise
05 Jan 2010
I have been thinking about writing this blog for a while now and decided it needed to become a priority when my own children presented some excellent questions about the origin of life! As a professional working with kids, I have identified my own comfort zone in how to respond to clients questions about religion, spirituality, and even some traditions. Instead of trying to educate my clients on the details of theology as I recognize I am not an expert in this area, I have opted to encourage their own self exploration by teaching them how to ask questions, explore their own beliefs, and always encouraging them to check the premise on which their existing beliefs stand. I also have thought a lot about how much power and influence that adults have over young peoples beliefs and I do not want to abuse this power by interjecting my own beliefs. So, I do refrain from sharing my personal beliefs or my own process of questioning with my clients. That does not work so well with my own children though as they do deserve answers to these questions from their mother….
So, I thought I would share a metaphor with all of you that has helped children learn how to check their own premise of their beliefs. I can not take credit for creating this metaphor as I heard a version of it from my husband about a decade ago…clearly not in relation to talking to kids about spirituality. So, I really do not know where it came from or who’s story it really was, but I have used it successfully over and over again. Here it is:
Once upon a time, there was an 8 year old boy, who loved to ask questions. Every year, he would look forward to his family’s Christmas celebration. Each year, his family would make a huge feast and play games on Christmas night. He loved spending time with his family and one year, the Christmas party was at his home so his mom was preparing most of the food for the feast. His family would always make a Christmas ham and this time, he was old enough to help his mom with the ham.
He was standing on a stool in the kitchen watching his mom prepare the ham. She got out the big pan, used the family recipe to make the ham drizzle sauce that she would pour all over the ham, and then proceeded to take a knife and cut off either end of the ham before she put it into the pan.
The boy asked, ”Mom, why do you need to cut of the ends?” His mom told him that she did not know but that is the way that her mother taught her to make the Christmas ham when she was growing up. The conversation really ended there…but the boys thoughts kept going (he is a thinker)!
Later that evening, when all of his family members were there, he decided to go ask his grandma why she taught his mom to cut off the ends of the ham. To his surprise, (he thought his grandma had all the answers), she said that she was taught that by her mother. For a while, the boy stopped thinking about it and played some games. Later that night, after they ate dinner, the seemingly strange question came back into his brain. Fotunately, his great grandmother was still alive and tended to sit in the same chair the whole night during the Christmas party. He was always a little uncomfortable talking with her because she was hard of hearing and that made him feel uncomfortable. Despite his relative discomfort, he did want to know the answer to his question. So, he went to the chair his great grandmother sits in and asked her simply, “Why is it important to cut the ends off of the ham before cooking it…mom and grandma did not know but said that was just how they were taught?” His great grandmother heard his question perfectly, looked at him with her gently and wise eyes and stated, “Honey, I needed to cut the ends of the ham because I never had a pan that was big enough to fit the whole thing!”
Wow, the boy was so proud that he figured this out. He of course, went to both his mother and grandmother to inform them that they do not need to cut the ends of the ham and proudly explained why. He great grandmother smiled with pride…as did he.
What a lesson this boy experienced in simply checking his premise (and that of his mother and grandmother too). Obviously, in the following annual Christmas parties to come, the family ate the whole ham and fondly told the story each year about how silly they were to cut the ends of the ham.
When kids hear this story, they get it! They do start asking their moms and dads (and grandparents) why they have taught them certain values, beliefs, traditions, and rituals. The amazing thing is that it always challenges the adults to check their own premise of their own beliefs and traditions. When I am processing this with young people, I sometimes ask them to think about all the rituals that are involved in a wedding. It is a common example that most people understand that is explosive with rituals that kids can easily research and break down. Some go the extra mile and actually find out where certain wedding traditions come from like throwing rice, throwing the brides flowers, lighting the unity candle, etc.
So, with all that said, I hope that you are all effectively challenged by children’s seemingly innocent questions as it is a growth process that you can embrace with your own children. Children also need to be given the space and time to come up with their own beliefs and create their own traditions as opposed to having all this simply handed to them. Think about how much that 8 year old boy gained from his process of questioning on that one Christmas night!
I certainly do not want to just trash all traditions as they are wonderful family experiences as well as social and cultural. I am simply encouraging kids to ask the why questions so they know why they repeat certain traditions, possess certain beliefs, and have certain emotions when traditions are performed. Lastly, kids love the opportunity to be the creator of new traditions!